« Anger on The Altar by Dominic Lee | Main | Only in Dublin by Dominic Lee »

October 17, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834656aad69e20120a646db43970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Lens hood & Tripod by Dominic Lee:

Comments

Chris Moody

"Take a photo of a green hedge at 1/250 sec and another at 1 second (naturally you must adjust your aperture to balance the exposure), what you will see is this: The hedge shot at 1/250 sec will be full of black areas and it will look like a snap taken by your average tourist with a pocket camera. The shot taken at a one second exposure will be bursting with luscious green leaves including the ones inside the hedge which are black in the 1/250 photo." - quote

As far as I understood it, 1 second at F22 delivers the same amount of light to the film/sensor as 1/250 at F1.4. Under controlled lighting the image should be identically exposed, shouldn't they? (We'll ignore light fall off at the edges at F1.4, narrow depth of field etc).

"There is light in those dark areas but the film/chip needs time for that light to register" - quote

Or a wider aperture, surely?

Now if the sun bursts through the clouds during the 1 second exposure that's different.

Dominic Lee

Chris, take a city street at night at 1/250 of a sec and another at 1 second, even though you can adjust the aperture to give both a correct exposure, you will have two totally different effects (shite and stunning). My advice is to stop using your aperture to allow in more light, use it to balance your meter reading but giving priority to long exposures which soak up the available light. There are lots of situations where this wont be possible but you would be surprised how slow you can shoot people standing still, even at 1/8 of a second (with a tripod). And your photos will look so different to every other snapper who stood beside you who was hand holding their camera at 1/60 or faster.
Dominic

Chris Moody

I agree entirely with the benefits of slower shutter/smaller aperture shooting - Greater depth of field, better sharpness across the sensor as well as the ability to bring 'movement' to a still image.

'giving priority to long exposures which soak up the available light' - quote

'There is light in those dark areas but the film/chip needs time for that light to register' - quote

Are you saying that using 1/250 at f4 exposes the sensor (or film) to less light than 1/125 at 5.6? The hedge example would suggest that.

In the instance of film I would agree that a longer exposure can sometimes result in more interesting colours and saturation due to reciprocity failure.

Dominic Lee

Chris's Question: "Are you saying that using 1/250 at f4 exposes the sensor (or film) to less light than 1/125 at 5.6? The hedge example would suggest that?"
Answer: No, just a different kind of light, light which may not be visible to the human eye but its there and it takes time for it to reach and effect the sensor! And no matter how wide you open the aperture it will never collect all the available light unless you allow it time, loads of time.
PS.This has nothing to do with reciprocity failure.
Dominic

Chris Moody

I'm sorry Dominic but I just don't understand your theory.

What is "a different kind of light"? - a light that seems to ignore the reciprocal relationship between aperture and shutter speed.

If you have the time/inclination could you post/email examples with metadata intact for me to look at.

I'm just curious.

Dominic Lee

Ye have to be wearing your Y-fronts and your crocodile hat, and then when you meet the rubber duck you twist his coconuts and stick the lot up the jelly giraffe’s aperture and as long as it’s not snowing your saxophone wont freeze and Bob the teapot will get you sorted!

Tony Maddox

I was wondering how you were going go out of that task Mr lee and you did by making me LOL. I love those rowntree randoms but I love the ads better. Tony

Chris

Ye have to be wearing your Y-fronts and your crocodile hat, and then when you meet the rubber duck you twist his coconuts and stick the lot up the jelly giraffe’s aperture and as long as it’s not snowing your saxophone wont freeze and Bob the teapot will get you sorted! - Why didn't just say that in the first place?

Michael McKay

Sadly the truth about this lens & tripod blog is that many so-called "photographers" reading that would say " what the hell is an aperture???? Drag the shutter -what's that all about??
Most point and shoot on Auto or Program mode!!!

M McKay

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

My Photo

Authors

  • Alan Murphy
    Photographer and Owner of The Irish Photographers Website - Ireland's No.1 Website for Professional Photographers!
  • SoapBox
    Trade insider who would rather stay unknown - You can speculate but we will never reveal.
  • Paddy Barker
    Trade Supplier and Assistant Picture Editor, Irish Examiner.
  • Dominic Lee
    Photographer
  • Tom Lawlor
    Photographer, Broadcaster and Media Commentator

Irish Photographers . org